Saturday 10 March 11:21 AM ET
Canada May Allow Jammers to Silence Cellphones

By Ian Karleff

TORONTO (Reuters) - The piercing ring of a mobile phone is enough to send many restaurant and movie patrons into a rage, but Canada's mobile phone industry is dead against the government forcing etiquette on the country's eight million users by legalizing signal jamming technology.

Industry Canada is planning to launch three months of public consultations into the use of the technology, which could be used to block cellular phone signals in restaurants, theaters, libraries or other locations.

''We're going to gather the widest public views possible on the use of cellphone silencers,'' said Industry Canada advisor David Warnes.

Warnes told the National Post newspaper that not only are there widespread complaints about cellphone use in public places but also inquiries by security firms that want to put jammers in corporate boardrooms to protect privacy.

The industry representing cellular phone manufacturers and network operators is firmly against legalizing signal jamming systems on the grounds that it could compromise public safety.

''Jamming technology is illegal here in Canada. We hope it would remain illegal,'' said Marc Choma, a spokesman for cellphone lobby group the Canadian Wireless Telecommunications Association. ''Our primary concern is public safety with three million (emergency) calls per year made to 911.''

Editors Note: it's either jamming or I take a rifle to those NON-courteous users whom use their cell phone in a bathroom in the airport, at the table, in the theater, while driving, and while walking. Take your pick: death or courtesy. You cannot have your cake and eat it two.

Cellular phones have long been advertised as indispensable tools in an emergency, and the industry is worried that this lifeline would be compromised with jamming technology.

Editors Note: what happens when that "shopping" or "my sisters sleeping with your husband" emergency claims life and property of someone not involved? When do we cross that line?

Lately, the industry has been under attack from multiple fronts as cellphones become ubiquitous, with critics saying mobile phones are health risks and many North American jurisdictions considering banning their use by drivers.

There are currently 8.3 million cellular phone users in Canada, up 27 percent from 1999, and this number is expected to grow by 25 to 30 percent in 2001.

Cellular phones are a fairly new invention and have only gained widespread popularity in the past few years, so it only makes sense that society has yet to self-regulate their usage, said Choma.

Editors Note: new? Try 1992

''Etiquette is not something we feel you can legislate. It will take a bit of time for Canadians to tell other Canadians what is right and wrong, and what is rude,'' added Choma.

Editors Note: let's face some reality. People are afraid of confrontation and the ones that are not are using their guns and rifles to get the point across. I don't think using weapons is what the Cell Phone industry really wants.

Vicki Whitmell, the executive director of the Canadian Library Association said she has yet to hear of problems with cellphones in libraries.

''I haven't heard anyone mention this issue and I would think it's partly the culture of libraries. People know how to use libraries and most libraries have had a policy in place regarding it for some time,'' she said.

Editors Note: I think the Canadian Cell Phone Industry had some "financial" influence on this statement.

Choma argues that rather than block the signals, users can be encouraged to turn the phones off in public places or set them to vibrate rather than ring. But these are the kinds of solutions that come from peer, rather than government pressure, he said.

Editors Note: if it was up to me, I would have done one of two things:

• I would have begun jamming and not said anything as most people would just assume the tower was off. But, they would have kept trying to use the phone anyway.
• I would have the system setup to send a sharp, piercing (Mariah Carey "Emotions" type) screech in the persons ear while they are in a public place or the cell phone signal is moving faster than 5 miles per hour. While cruel and inhumane some may say, this would deem most effective (like a psychological experiment).